Podfic Feedback Challenge!

idella 346
dodificus 247
miss_marina95 220
klb 205
podfic_lover 149
pi 120
cantarina 109
kalakirya 98
yue_ix 94
luzula 83
knight_tracer 79
hardboiledbaby 77
sklee 65
regonym 42
niko 41
boxofdelights 40
mistressjinx 39
lunate8 34
off_the_map 27
greedy_dancer 25
paraka 25
anatsuno 17
erica_schall 17
glittertine 16


Congratulations to everyone who participated, I hope you had fun and I'll see you again next year:D

Sometimes it can be difficult to find new podfics, you *want* to try something new but it can be hard to know where to start.

Post a comment with a rec to a podfic you love and think is under-rated, check out other people's recs, try one you haven't listened to and leave feedback. Easy! Maybe the podfic you rec will even be one you discovered during the challenge!

Listen to a podfic rec'd in the comments and leave feedback for the reader, earn 10 points for each piece of feedback you leave

It occurred to me that some people might misinterpret how to score points, so I'm just going to clarify and hope I haven't stuffed a bunch of you up:

You can't give yourself points for the challenges + points from the regular points scale.

ie: If you're claiming 5 points for being the first to comment (mini challenge 1) you can't *also* claim points for reccing (another 5 points). It's either/or.

Does that make sense? How many of you did I confuse by not clarifying this earlier?

Meantime: I'm loving see the # of pages of uncommented podfics shrink:D How's everyone going?

This is basically the same Intro post from last year with a few additions/changes

Just a short post giving you an idea what you can expect from the challenge and how it's going to work. This is also a great place to ask any questions and hopefully I'll have an answer for you:)


I think most podficcers are of the mind that any feedback is better than no feedback! So, while you might feel like you ought to write a multi-paragraph ode to someone's accent/style/technical genius, sometimes all you really have to say is that you enjoyed it. And that's ok!

Challenge yourself to leave some kind of feedback for every podfic that you listen to during the 2 weeks of the challenge and hopefully you'll be inspired by the mini challenges that pop up throughout to stretch your feedbacking skills even further.

If you're not sure what to say in your comments, check out klb's Podfic Feedback Toolbox: 5 ways to give great podfic feedback or hear it read aloud by knight_tracer. It has a nice variety of examples and is just generally an overall interesting post on feedback in podfic fandom.


Points

For each piece of feedback that you give we're scoring as follows:

Leave basic feedback: 3 points
Example: Great job, I had fun listening to this!

Leave feedback with specifics about what you enjoyed: 4 points
Example: It was a treat listening to this while I was out walking today. I could hear the affection for the characters in your voice, and I loved the song you added at the end.

Leave feedback with specifics about what you enjoyed PLUS rec it somewhere accessible to fandom at large: 5 points

Places you could rec: your personal journal/tumblr/blog or a public reccing space like podficpool


For the purposes of this challenge, giving a kudos/liking does not count as giving feedback and wont be counted in the points system.


There will be a post one week in and then another at the end of the second week where you can log your points and mini challenges posted every few days to boost your points.

At the end of the 2 weeks points will be tallied up and we will see who has been the most awesome at letting podficcers know how much they're loved.

In conclusion: listen to the podfics you normally would, give feedback, get points, join in on the challenges if you so desire, most importantly: have fun! ETA: The podfic you feedback *doesn't have to be ones you've listened to in the space of the 2 week challenge*, it can be a chance to catch up on your backlog.

Remember the challenge doesn't start until May 11th and ends May 25th

Another year, another round of the Podfic Appreciation Challenge\o/

We ran for a month last year, I'm considering only running the challenge for a week this time, I'd love your feedback.




Also: feel free to suggest ideas for the mini challenges or cast your mind back and tell me if there were any you hated from last year.